Skip to main content

Why did an order not include a free gift

Missing a free gift on an order? Learn the common reasons a gift wasn’t added to the cart, how to check each one, and how to prevent it.

If a customer’s order is missing a gift you expected them to receive, it’s for one of the reasons below. Each section explains what happens and what you can do about it.


​

1. Auto add to cart was not turned on

Gifts are only added to the cart automatically when the Auto add product to cart setting is turned on for the reward. If it’s off, the customer qualifies for the gift but nothing is added, and they would need to add it themselves via the reward information box add to cart button or via the product page.

How to check: Open the Add to unlock block and confirm Auto add product to cart is turned on for that reward.

What you can do:

  • Turn the setting on for any offer where the gift should be added without the customer doing anything.

  • If you intentionally leave it off, make your gift messaging clear that the customer needs to add the gift themselves.

2. The customer removed the gift from their cart

When a customer reaches a gift threshold and the gift is added to their cart automatically. If the cart allows edits of the gift item, the customer can remove the gift themselves, either on purpose or by accident, for example by tapping the remove button while tidying their cart. The app respects that removal and doesn’t add the gift back, even if the cart still qualifies until they clear their cart.

How to prevent it: Turn on Prevent product(s) quantity edits or removals in cart. With this setting on, customers can’t change the quantity of a gift or remove it, so it stays in the cart through to checkout.

3. The gift needed a selection and the customer didn’t choose one

Some gifts need the customer to choose before they’re added, either a product from a list of options or a variant such as a size or colour. In these cases a popup appears when the customer qualifies if Auto add product to cart is turned on. If the customer closes the popup or continues without choosing, no gift is added to the cart.

They can reopen the popup by clicking the add to cart button in the reward information box if you have the box visible.

What you can do:

  • Make sure your gift messaging makes it clear that the customer needs to pick their gift.

  • If a gift only has one option, set it up as a single product or variant so no selection is needed.

4. The gift was out of stock

A gift can only be added if at least one variant of the gift product is in stock. If every variant is out of stock, the Add to unlock reward option is hidden and the gift can’t be added to the cart, even though the customer has met the threshold. This can happen part way through a promotion if the gift sells out or its inventory is adjusted.

How to check: Look at the gift product’s inventory in Shopify and confirm at least one variant was in stock at the time of the order.

What you can do:

  • Keep enough gift stock on hand to cover the expected demand for the promotion.

  • Check gift inventory regularly during busy periods.

  • If the gift has sold out, pause or end the offer, or update your messaging, so customers aren’t expecting a gift that can’t be added.

5. Some add-on products don’t count toward the threshold

Products added through certain features don’t contribute to a gift threshold, so a cart can look like it qualifies when it doesn’t. This catches out stores that use them for add-ons like shipping protection or returns cover.

The following don’t count toward unlocking a threshold:

  • One-tick upsell products, when Include in cart offers is not ticked.

  • Checkout button optional products.

If a customer’s cart total only reached the threshold because of one of these add-ons, the gift won’t unlock and won’t be added.
​

How to check: Add up the order’s merchandise lines only, leaving out any shipping protection, returns cover or similar add-ons. If that total is below the threshold, this is the likely cause.
​

What you can do:

  • For one-tick upsell products, tick Include in cart offers if you want them to count.

  • Make your gift messaging clear that the threshold is based on product value, not the order total including add-ons.
    ​

6. The cart was created before the offer went live

A gift is only added when the app evaluates the cart while the offer is live on the storefront. If a customer’s cart or checkout session started before the offer went live, the app may never have evaluated it, so the gift isn’t added even though the cart total meets the threshold.

This usually happens when:

  • The customer was already at checkout when the offer went live. The offer started while they were partway through paying.

  • The customer returned straight to checkout with a cart created before the offer went live. This is common when they click through from an abandoned cart email or reopen an old browser session. This is also a risk when you get customers to build their carts in hype. The cart was created before the offer started, and they went directly to checkout without visiting the storefront where the app could evaluate it.

How to check: Compare the offer’s start date and time with when the customer’s cart was created. If the cart came first and the customer went straight to checkout, this is the likely cause.

What you can do:

  • Avoid starting or changing offers at peak trading times, when many customers are likely to be mid-checkout.

  • Be aware that abandoned cart emails often return customers directly to the Shopify checkout page.

  • Ensure customers visits the storefront when returning

  • Ensure the customer refreshes their browser when on the storefront if the offer is not yet visible to them.

7. The customer didn’t qualify under the offer’s settings

Sometimes the cart looks like it should have earned the gift, but the offer’s settings mean it didn’t. The gift only unlocks when the cart meets every condition set on the reward, so a customer can seem to qualify without actually doing so.

Common causes include:

  • The threshold wasn’t met by the right products. The reward may only count certain products or collections, so the cart total can look high enough without qualifying.

  • A price or discount changed the total. If prices were reduced or a discount applied, the cart value used for the threshold may have been lower than the customer expected.

How to check: Open the reward and review its settings, including the threshold, which products count to unlock it.

What you can do:

  • Test the cart yourself. Build a cart with the same products as the customer’s order and see whether the gift unlocks.

  • If the test cart doesn’t unlock the gift, adjust the offer’s settings or your messaging so customers know what they need to qualify.

8. The order wasn’t placed through the storefront

Gifts are added by the app while the customer is browsing and building their cart on your online store only. If the customer buys through another channel, the app never evaluates the cart, so no gift is added even though the order total meets the threshold.

This usually happens when the customer buys through:

  • The Shop app, either by checking out directly from the app or from a product page inside it.

  • Express checkout or a buy now button on product pages, which can take the customer straight to checkout without going through the cart.

  • Another sales channel or mechanism, such as social media shopping, a marketplace, a draft order, a point of sale (POS) order or an order created by a developer or other app.

How to check: Open the order in Shopify and look if there has been a Unicorn cart id set in the order attributes.

What you can do:

  • Make your gift messaging clear that the offer applies to orders placed on your online store.

  • If you want to honour the gift for a customer who bought another way, add it to the order manually, and apply the discount to the gift line only.

9. Another app interfered with the cart

Some apps on your store may intercept or change cart API requests, for example to add their own products or change prices. When this happens, the request our app sends to add or remove a gift can be altered or blocked. The gift may not be added, may not be discounted, or may not be removed when the cart drops below the threshold.

How to check: Look at the apps installed on your store for any that modify the cart. Then test a qualifying cart with that app’s cart features turned off and see whether the problem goes away.

What you can do:

  • Contact the other app’s support and ask whether it can be configured not to interfere with other apps’ cart requests.

  • Turn off the conflicting feature if you don’t need it.

  • Include the names of any cart-related apps when you contact us.

10. The automatic add API request failed

When a customer qualifies, the app sends an API request to Shopify to add the gift to the cart. In very rare cases this request fails, either because of a network connectivity problem on the customer’s side or because Shopify’s servers rejected it. The app does not control the success of this request. The app doesn’t retry a failed request.

If the Reward information box is visible on your store, the customer can add the gift manually from there. This is very rare, but it’s worth making sure the box is visible so customers have a way to recover.

Liability

We’re not liable if a gift is not added to a cart or doesn’t appear on an order, whatever the reason, including those listed above. Gifts depend on customer actions, network connections and Shopify’s own systems, which are outside our control. We recommend checking your cart settings and testing your gift offers on your store before and during any promotion.

Still not sure why a gift was missing?

If you’ve worked through all the reasons above and still can’t explain a missing gift, contact support. To help us look into it quickly, please follow these guidelines.

Send us an example order number, not a full list. We investigate individual orders in detail, so a single order is only accepted. If you have many affected orders, pick one that represent the pattern and we’ll tell you what we find. In most cases the same cause applies to the rest. Requests with a long list of orders may be sent back and asked to be narrowed down.

Choose orders that fit these criteria:

  • Orders where you’ve already ruled out ALL the reasons above.

  • Orders that look typical of the problem, rather than unusual cases.

Include the following for each order:

  • The order number.

  • The name of the gift offer the customer should have received and threshold it unlocks at.

  • What you expected to happen and what actually happened.

  • Whether the order was edited after it was placed, such as a gift added manually.

We’ll review the order and let you know the cause within a few days.

Did this answer your question?