If a customer’s order includes a gift product but they were charged for it, it’s for one of the reasons below. Each section explains what happens and what you can do about it.
1. Another discount overruled the gift discount
The gift is made free by a product discount created by the app in Shopify. If the customer also used a discount code, or an automatic discount applied to the cart, and that discount isn’t set to combine with the free gift discount, Shopify may apply only one of them. If the other discount wins, the gift is charged at full price.
How to check: Open the order and look at the discounts applied. If the gift line has no discount, or a different discount than expected, this is the likely cause.
What you can do:
Open the other discount in Shopify discounts and check its Combinations settings. Allow it to combine with product discounts.
Test a cart with the gift and the other discount applied together to confirm both work.
If you still have discount combinations issues or are unable to change existing discounts created by 3rd party apps then you can set the gift product to $0 which will bypass the automatic discount.
If the discount combination issue can not be solved using the previous methods then you can create a product with a $0 price to use a free gift.
2. The customer manually added an additional free gift product
If the customer changes the quantity of the gift, or adds the same product as a paid item, the extra units aren’t covered by the gift discount and are charged at full price.
How to check: Look at the order lines for more than one line, or a quantity above 1, for the gift product.
What you can do:
Turn on Prevent product(s) quantity edits or removals in cart so customers can’t change the gift’s quantity.
3. Auto remove was turned off
The gift is added when the customer reaches the threshold, but it only comes out of the cart if the Auto remove product(s) if the reward threshold is no longer met setting is turned on. If it’s off and the customer removes items and drops below the threshold, the gift stays in the cart. It no longer qualifies for the discount, so the customer is charged full price for it.
What you can do:
Turn the setting on for any reward where the gift should only stay in the cart while the threshold is met.
If you intentionally leave it off, make your messaging clear that the gift is only free while the cart meets the threshold.
4. The app’s discount was deleted or disabled in Shopify
Each gift offer relies on a product discount in Shopify discounts. If that discount is deleted or deactivated, the gift can still be added to the cart but nothing makes it free, so the customer pays full price.
How to check: Go to Shopify Discounts and confirm the discount linked to the offer exists and is active
What you can do:
Don’t delete or deactivate the app’s discounts in Shopify. Manage the offer from the app instead.
If a discount was removed by mistake, turn the offer off and on again in the app and save.
5. The offer was turned off while the gift was in the cart or the customer was at checkout
If you turn off or end an offer while a customer already has the gift in their cart, or while they’re partway through checkout, the discount stops applying. The gift can remain in the cart and be charged at full price.
How to check: Compare the time the offer was turned off or ended with the order time and the customer’s cart activity.
What you can do:
Avoid turning off or ending offers at peak trading times, when many customers are likely to be mid-checkout.
If you need to end an offer, consider scheduling it for a quiet period.
Remember that customers may keep a cart open for hours or days, or return from an email so a gift can be in a cart long after the offer ends.
If you want to ensure the gift is removed from customers carts set the gift product to draft or the stock to 0.
6. The cart value changed after the gift unlocked and gift no longer qualified to be free
The gift unlocks based on the cart at the time it’s evaluated. If prices change while the customer is at checkout, for example a sale starts, a discount applies, or a price is edited, the merchandise total can fall below the threshold even though the gift is still in the cart. The gift is then charged for.
How to check: Compare the prices on the order with the prices when the items were added. If the total at the order’s prices is below the threshold, this is the likely cause.
What you can do:
Avoid changing prices or starting sales while customers have active carts at checkout.
Think about how sale pricing interacts with your gift thresholds before launching a promotion.
7. Another app interfered with the cart API request
Some apps on your store may intercept or change cart API requests, for example to add their own products or change prices. When this happens, the request our app sends to add or remove a gift can be altered or blocked. The gift may not be added, may not be discounted, or may not be removed when the cart drops below the threshold.
How to check: Look at the apps installed on your store for any that modify the cart. Then test a qualifying cart with that app’s cart features turned off and see whether the problem goes away.
What you can do:
Contact the other app’s support and ask whether it can be configured not to interfere with other apps’ cart requests.
Turn off the conflicting feature if you don’t need it.
Include the names of any cart-related apps when you contact us.
8. Another app removed the Unicorn cart attributes
Other apps can sometimes accidentally wipe cart attributes. Unicorn stores its cart ID there so the app can identify which cart is being used. When it’s removed, the app can’t match the order to a Unicorn cart, so the gift may be added but not discounted.
How to check: Open the order in Shopify and look at the additional details or note attributes. If the _unicorn_cart_id entry is missing, the attributes were removed.
What you can do:
Identify any app or custom code that updates the cart or its attributes, and ask its support whether it can be configured to preserve other apps’ data.
Turn off the conflicting feature if you don’t need it.
Include the names of any cart-related apps when you contact us.
9. The automatic remove API request failed
When a customer reaches the threshold, the gift is added. If they then remove an item and fall below the threshold, the app sends an API request to Shopify to remove the gift. In very rare cases this request fails, either because of a network connectivity problem on the customer’s side or because Shopify’s servers rejected it. The app does not control the success of this request. The app doesn’t retry a failed request.
How to check: Add up the order’s merchandise lines, excluding the gift. If the total is below the threshold, this is a likely cause.
What you can do:
Make sure your messaging explains that the gift is only free while the cart meets the threshold.
Where a customer was clearly shown the gift as unlocked and charged for it, consider whether to refund it as a goodwill gesture.
Liability
We’re not liable if a gift is charged for or a discount doesn’t apply to an order, whatever the reason, including those listed above. Discounts depend on customer actions, your store’s discount settings, network connections and Shopify’s own systems, which are outside our control. We recommend checking your discounts and testing your gift offers before and during any promotion.
Still not sure why a gift was missing?
If you’ve worked through all the reasons above and still can’t explain a missing gift, contact support. To help us look into it quickly, please follow these guidelines.
Send us an example order number, not a full list. We investigate individual orders in detail, so a single order is only accepted. If you have many affected orders, pick one that represent the pattern and we’ll tell you what we find. In most cases the same cause applies to the rest. Requests with a long list of orders may be sent back and asked to be narrowed down.
Choose orders that fit these criteria:
Orders where you’ve already ruled out ALL the reasons above.
Orders that look typical of the problem, rather than unusual cases.
Include the following for each order:
The order number.
The name of the gift offer the customer should have received and threshold it unlocks at.
What you expected to happen and what actually happened.
Whether the order was edited after it was placed, such as a gift added manually.
We’ll review the order and let you know the cause within a few days.
